Got this for free from the publisher's table at a conference! Excited to check it out.
User Profile
I'm an ex-"tech" worker and now a scholar, with have a deep passion for linguistics (BS in Communication Sciences and Disorders) and games (video and tabletop). I'm currently pursuing an MA in the humanities (graduating April), which I use to study games (video and tabletop), themed and immersive experiences (almost exclusively theme parks), film/TV (scifi, superhero, action, animation), and politics in/of media. I then start my PhD this autumn, DMs open!
This link opens in a pop-up window
FossilPoet's books
2024 Reading Goal
7% complete! FossilPoet has read 2 of 26 books.
User Activity
RSS feed Back
FossilPoet wants to read Fredric Jameson and Film Theory by Fredric Jameson
FossilPoet replied to FossilPoet's status
Super important book, not just for its time but into today. My only real complaint is it feels like it restates its points over and over again, either in/across sections, chapters, or "schemas." The language is otherwise very accessible and the text full of great examples.
Notably, this is the text that popularized the concept of the "magic circle" in game studies. Having fully read it now, I can see that it was grossly taken out of context. The authors themselves anticipated and problematized it long before others took to abuse of the term, debate over it, and restructuring it back to what it already was.
FossilPoet rated Rules of Play: 4 stars
Rules of Play by Eric Zimmerman, Katie Salen Tekinbaş
An impassioned look at games and game design that offers the most ambitious framework for understanding them to date.
As …
FossilPoet finished reading Rules of Play by Eric Zimmerman
Rules of Play by Eric Zimmerman, Katie Salen Tekinbaş
An impassioned look at games and game design that offers the most ambitious framework for understanding them to date.
As …
FossilPoet stopped reading Why We Need Ordinary Language Philosophy by Sandra Laugier
FossilPoet replied to Babel Molotov's status
@suzyxwvu septentrio.uit.no/index.php/nordlit/article/view/5016 Curious your feelings on this.
FossilPoet stopped reading Keywords for Disability Studies by Benjamin Reiss (Keywords, #7)
FossilPoet stopped reading A Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations by Kate L. Turabian (Chicago Guides to Writing, Editing, and Publishing)
FossilPoet started reading Doing Ethnography Today by Luke Eric Lassiter
FossilPoet started reading Rules of Play by Eric Zimmerman
Rules of Play by Eric Zimmerman, Katie Salen Tekinbaş
An impassioned look at games and game design that offers the most ambitious framework for understanding them to date.
As …
FossilPoet replied to FossilPoet's status
I don't want to underestimate the goodness of this book's aims: it's worth a read. It is, however, repetitive and circular as all sin in its examples. There's also an extreme devotion to art history overlaid on a broad interpretation of play (as opposed to the narrower categories of game or game design the title may imply), to the extent you don't really get to any sense of what use critical play is in games until the last chapter.
That doesn't change how my mind did wander to the utility of artistic thought in game design and related projects. It just ended up being a bit more distracting than what I went in thinking about, which is a critical game design such as that being explored in an issue of Design Issues from last year.
FossilPoet rated Critical Play: 3 stars
Critical Play by Mary Flanagan
An examination of subversive games—games designed for political, aesthetic, and social critique.
For many players, games are entertainment, diversion, relaxation, …
FossilPoet finished reading Critical Play by Mary Flanagan
Critical Play by Mary Flanagan
An examination of subversive games—games designed for political, aesthetic, and social critique.
For many players, games are entertainment, diversion, relaxation, …