crabbygirl reviewed Divergent (Divergent, #1) by Veronica Roth (Divergent trilogy)
Review of 'Divergent (Divergent, #1)' on 'Goodreads'
2 stars
hmm. i usually enjoy teen dystopian novels because of the obvious parallels to the alien universe of highschool with it's numerous cliches, hierarchy and power strangleholds. so the concept of joining your tribe at 16 initially appealed to me. but then the heroine does the exact thing every teen would want: abandons their parents, manners, and the tiresome practice of putting others' needs in front of you - and embraces the thrills and selfishness of a tattooed and body-pierced tribe.
everything about the book seemed designed to translate easily to a movie, starting with the initial choosing ceremony where teens individually come forward to cut the palm of their hand with a knife, and then drip their blood into one of 5 symbolic vessels. huh? cutting open your palm? the author pretty much gives away the direction of the novel when she opens with an action that would be feared …
hmm. i usually enjoy teen dystopian novels because of the obvious parallels to the alien universe of highschool with it's numerous cliches, hierarchy and power strangleholds. so the concept of joining your tribe at 16 initially appealed to me. but then the heroine does the exact thing every teen would want: abandons their parents, manners, and the tiresome practice of putting others' needs in front of you - and embraces the thrills and selfishness of a tattooed and body-pierced tribe.
everything about the book seemed designed to translate easily to a movie, starting with the initial choosing ceremony where teens individually come forward to cut the palm of their hand with a knife, and then drip their blood into one of 5 symbolic vessels. huh? cutting open your palm? the author pretty much gives away the direction of the novel when she opens with an action that would be feared and/or intellectually challenged by any tribe that wasn't the protagonist's choice of 'dauntless'
and yet, for a plot that requires children to launch into adulthood at 16, the topic of sex is so mysterious and worrisome that it's actually a vivid fear for the main character, along with shooting her family, drowning, and being pecked to death by crows.