Review of 'The Shadow and Bone Trilogy Boxed Set: Shadow and Bone, Siege and Storm, Ruin and Rising' on 'Goodreads'
2 stars
A grim opener to a series, I confess that although I enjoyed it for itself, I'm not overly sunk on following up. I enjoy some bleak fiction, but there's a nebulous nature to the powers called that has yet to really be defined and, if I'm being brutal, I've just spent 22 chapters reading about an orphan girl hiding her powers because of another orphan while some sort of centuries old planner tries to bring things to fruition. We've not yet been told about any ancient or mysterious reason for this, the old-woman-as-mother trope was easy to spot from the beginning and almost everything present was muted: - the training for talented kids although set in a palace was only briefly covered. The creepy priesthood is very much underrepresented by the apparat. The political mess of the other lands only really comes into any sort of meaning in the final …
A grim opener to a series, I confess that although I enjoyed it for itself, I'm not overly sunk on following up. I enjoy some bleak fiction, but there's a nebulous nature to the powers called that has yet to really be defined and, if I'm being brutal, I've just spent 22 chapters reading about an orphan girl hiding her powers because of another orphan while some sort of centuries old planner tries to bring things to fruition. We've not yet been told about any ancient or mysterious reason for this, the old-woman-as-mother trope was easy to spot from the beginning and almost everything present was muted: - the training for talented kids although set in a palace was only briefly covered. The creepy priesthood is very much underrepresented by the apparat. The political mess of the other lands only really comes into any sort of meaning in the final chapter, and the actual people are really only given form in the hierarchy of Corporalki versus Summoners, with serving girls who don't know their place, Orphans with mysterious scars, and trackers who never actually explain their tallents and seem overpowered to the story anyway.
A quite unsettling mix of things which, I would hope in future works, would fall onto a more even keel but for me here and now left me felt a touch disappointed.
