Sara G reviewed The mystery of three quarters by Sophie Hannah (Hercule poirot mysteries)
Review of 'The mystery of three quarters' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
I liked that this story had a different structure to the previous two Hercule Poirot novels Sophie Hannah has written, the premise was clever, as was the ultimate reveal at the end, but I again felt like puzzle was needlessly complicated. I had hoped that once the author settled into a rhythm of writing Poirot, and stopped trying to prove her worth as a whodunit crafts-person, the mysteries might relax into something more believable, but I found myself distracted from the cleverness of the solution by how unlikely all the individual elements are.
Some of the characters are well developed though I did find the children unbelievable, they were far too grown up. The post-reveal conclusion was somewhat rushed and unsatisfying. Catchpool feels a bit toned down in his objections and annoyance, but he's still not an immensely likeable character.
I'll read more of these books as they are released, …
I liked that this story had a different structure to the previous two Hercule Poirot novels Sophie Hannah has written, the premise was clever, as was the ultimate reveal at the end, but I again felt like puzzle was needlessly complicated. I had hoped that once the author settled into a rhythm of writing Poirot, and stopped trying to prove her worth as a whodunit crafts-person, the mysteries might relax into something more believable, but I found myself distracted from the cleverness of the solution by how unlikely all the individual elements are.
Some of the characters are well developed though I did find the children unbelievable, they were far too grown up. The post-reveal conclusion was somewhat rushed and unsatisfying. Catchpool feels a bit toned down in his objections and annoyance, but he's still not an immensely likeable character.
I'll read more of these books as they are released, but I'm not incredibly impressed.