crabbygirl reviewed Girlhood by Melissa Febos
Review of 'Girlhood' on 'Goodreads'
1 star
following the essay format almost too closely (wide platitude to narrow thesis), most intros started with greek myths that were too obscure - making the 'capture your audience first' part of the essay fall flat for me. Then there was the actual content of the essays: sex work as a dominatrix, addiction to heroine, embracing the concept of slut: stuff that might surprise a reader (like me) who thought a book entitled "Girlhood" would be about the more universal difficulties of puberty.
but all bad books contain something for me to learn and this is my takeaway: perhaps my longing to be a popular girl was birthed and thwarted when I was a late bloomer and that maybe the social stratification of middle and high school girls is destiny based on the timetables of puberty (sort of like Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers where professional hockey players are mostly born in the …
following the essay format almost too closely (wide platitude to narrow thesis), most intros started with greek myths that were too obscure - making the 'capture your audience first' part of the essay fall flat for me. Then there was the actual content of the essays: sex work as a dominatrix, addiction to heroine, embracing the concept of slut: stuff that might surprise a reader (like me) who thought a book entitled "Girlhood" would be about the more universal difficulties of puberty.
but all bad books contain something for me to learn and this is my takeaway: perhaps my longing to be a popular girl was birthed and thwarted when I was a late bloomer and that maybe the social stratification of middle and high school girls is destiny based on the timetables of puberty (sort of like Malcolm Gladwell's Outliers where professional hockey players are mostly born in the first 3 months of the year, giving them a leg up and opportunities not afforded to the late-in-the-year birthdays) Because this book made me think of something I never have: How do shy 11 and 12 year olds, with no agency to speak of, or peers, or role models, handle being the 'experimental' firsts down the puberty pathway? How do they escape the eyes and clutches of older boys when they present as 16 year olds? What to do with the acquiescent nature of girls when the very act of acquiescence in young womanhood marks you as easy, as a slut?