Ninth House - Rambling Readers

Diego Delgado reviewed La Novena Casa by Leigh Bardugo

Review of 'La Novena Casa' on 'Goodreads'

5 stars

Hay magia negra, fantasmas, sociedades secretas y vida universitaria, pero esta novela es en realidad una crítica al sufrimiento atroz sobre el que se funda el sistema capitalista. Un sufrimiento que, además, carga todo su doloroso peso en las desposeídas: mujeres, personas racializadas, pobres, disidentes y neurodivergentes ven su vida consumida para que los privilegiados mantengan su poder.

Radioactivestardust reviewed Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo (Alex Stern, #1)

Review of 'Ninth House' on 'Goodreads'

4 stars

I have never seen such horrible marketing for a book. If you understand anything about the story from reading the blurb you are 100% smarter than me, because I did not get anything. If I would have written the blurb it would have gone something like this:

Since she was a kid, Alex Stern was able to see ghosts. That led to a horrible childhood, drug abuse as teenager and a bloody homicide. But Alex survived. When she was approached by the Dean of Lethe House for her special skill, she won the jackpot to finally make something out of her life. A full sponsorship at Yale University. Her only task? Take care of the societies at Yale that deal in black magic, don't fuck up. Until they do, under her watch and an innocent girl dies. Alex now needs to figure out, who was the murder.

Doesn't this sound …

I have never seen such horrible marketing for a book. If you understand anything about the story from reading the blurb you are 100% smarter than me, because I did not get anything. If I would have written the blurb it would have gone something like this:

Since she was a kid, Alex Stern was able to see ghosts. That led to a horrible childhood, drug abuse as teenager and a bloody homicide. But Alex survived. When she was approached by the Dean of Lethe House for her special skill, she won the jackpot to finally make something out of her life. A full sponsorship at Yale University. Her only task? Take care of the societies at Yale that deal in black magic, don't fuck up. Until they do, under her watch and an innocent girl dies. Alex now needs to figure out, who was the murder.

Doesn't this sound clear? Now you can actually understand what is going on. Isn't that amazing. And all we would have needed was the word "ghost".

Instead, reading the beginning was hard. It basically threw me in a 3 week reading slump. And I am really angry about that.

This is also not a "dark academia", this is a very well written paranormal fantasy. Why did the publishers not use the word? Because they were scared it would seem cheap.
In the end, it is your regular paranormal fantasy.

It took forever until I understood what was actually going on. I had to spend 3 hours at one point to reread the story, to understand the plot and what is actually happening. Bardugo hid all the hints in ass long paragraphs of unnecessary detail. But the details we would have needed for real world building weren't available. This is the biggest flaw. Real bad world building. I still have so many questions that have not been answered

Nevertheless, I loved the dark vibe of the book. Apparently I like horror things (not the crime part, that was horrible annoying) but the action and the dark magic and the bad pasts (because it feels more real). I love Darlington (who doesn't? But let's face it, he is a 90% copycat of Gansey) and the writing was great.
It followed several plot lines that layered each other and open up a lot of possibilities for coming books.
The book feels written like a dark paranormal fantasy Netflix series. I had a ton of images in my head which would work for a TV show adaption. The writing was very vivid and the characters mostly well done (beside Dawes, still don't know who she is)

Emily Johnson

rated it

Sep 25