Review of 'The best time travel stories of the 20th century' on 'Storygraph'
4 stars
I think I have to give an addendum to my rating. The research in this book was great, tons of fun. It was easy to get swept up in Morley's exuberance about the buildings, the people, the rural young New York he found himself surrounded in. At times the details are almost too fine, but he can be forgiven. I'm sure if I wrote an account of my trip to 1880s New York it'd be just as involved.
The plot, being a bit of a mystery, worked well too. If in doubt, nothing gets a plot moving like a good hunded-year-old mystery.
I often felt that Morley had extremely rose-tinted views of absolutely everything—the food was better (he managed to avoid flour cut with sawdust or days old meat or food-borne illness, this was all prior to any food regulatory body) the beer was better, everything. No horse poop. No …
I think I have to give an addendum to my rating. The research in this book was great, tons of fun. It was easy to get swept up in Morley's exuberance about the buildings, the people, the rural young New York he found himself surrounded in. At times the details are almost too fine, but he can be forgiven. I'm sure if I wrote an account of my trip to 1880s New York it'd be just as involved.
The plot, being a bit of a mystery, worked well too. If in doubt, nothing gets a plot moving like a good hunded-year-old mystery.
I often felt that Morley had extremely rose-tinted views of absolutely everything—the food was better (he managed to avoid flour cut with sawdust or days old meat or food-borne illness, this was all prior to any food regulatory body) the beer was better, everything. No horse poop. No cholera or typhoid or tuberculosis, the lucky man. Poverty gets mentioned, several times, but it still feels awfully distant than the easy privilege he falls into when he shows up.
And maybe this is a symptom of the time period they were written in... But though there were very well developed, interesting female characters with intelligence and personality, and though Morley purported to view them as equals, he described them so patronizingly. Like extremely capable children. Made me twitchy.