Back

I’ve been working my way through the trans-related YA books available at my local library and thought I’d share my thoughts, starting with those I enjoyed the most and ending with those I couldn’t quite take up a position on.

Note that most (all?) of these are American, and I've never been to the States, so that may affect how I read and relate to these stories.

replied to Kai Ash's status

May The Best Man Win, by Z. R. Ellor.

This book's reviews on The Story Graph weren't too promising, but then it was marketed as a rom-com, which it is not. It’s a coming of age story about two emotionally messy teenage boys who happen to adore each other in a very chaotic way.

I particularly liked the way this book dealt with anger. I feel like not enough queer books tackle the emotion of fury enough.

Cover art for May the Best Man Win. Two boys - one in a gridiron helmet - face off against each other against a pink and yellow background.

replied to Kai Ash's status

Stay Gold, by Tobly McSmith

I liked this book. There were a few struggles (e.g., why did the protagonist use the name "Pony" if he felt so strongly about being stealth? Maybe the name reads as more cis/masc in Texas?)

I most enjoyed the characters' relationship dynamics. They weren't always clean, but they felt real, and there was just enough supportive love to help the reader through the darker chapters.

Cover art for Stay Gold. Two teens - a boy and a girl - sit on the roof of a car, watching the sunset.

replied to Kai Ash's status

Most Ardently, by Gabe Cole Novoa

I can't deny that the book reads like fanfiction, but it was great fun nonetheless. It's exactly what it says on the tin: a trans and gay retelling of Pride & Prejudice.

The pedant in me objected to some of the structural story changes (e.g., everyone was aged down). I was also bothered by some of the historical inaccuracies. But it's fiction, so best just enjoy the ride.

Cover art for Most Ardently. Two young men stand back to back, one reading and one pulling a letter out of their jacket. The reading one appears to be reaching for the other, who is turned slightly to peek over his shoulder.