I'm certainly liking the approach here. It also seems to suggest that rationality can be broader than, say, concepts like logical validity, and include other kinds of discursive games or dialogue goals that shape what constitutes "rational" (i.e., justified/justifiable or prescribed) speech. At the same time, it seems obvious that certain kinds of dialogue, or discursive games, are paradigmatic to us when discussing what reasoning looks like externally. The paradigmatic case still benefits from seeing how it is embedded into other speech activities. I feel like this is what would allow us to truly have the discussion, for example, about whether LLMs can reason or not.
Reviews and Comments
Primarily a nonfiction reader/collector with a dash of poetry or short story anthologies. Fiction typically is speculative fiction, some variation of sci-fi, dark fantasy, occult detective fiction, cosmic and psychological or domestic horror.
For non-fiction, I seek books in philosophy, sociology or social theory, the life sciences, religious studies, media studies, ethnic or area studies, gender & sexuality studies, and reference or study books for technical subjects like formal logic, mathematics, computer science and mechanics.
This link opens in a pop-up window
metascribe commented on Informal Logic by Douglas N. Walton
metascribe started reading Informal Logic by Douglas N. Walton
Inadvertently I start reading new books when I'm still stewing on and note-taking other ones. It takes some time, especially with non-fiction, for some ideas to really sink in, and for me to make connections, let alone write them down or do an annotated bibliography. Well, I've undeniably started this one. That doesn't mean I'll be sure to finish it.
I really sank some time into this one compared to the other two or three books I've been reading on and off. Certainly am learning a lot. I remember getting up to musical scales last time with a different music theory book, and kind of hitting a wall of understanding. This book has helped get past that, gradually discerning what is at first ambiguity in the music vocabulary.
I found myself watching some music analysis videos on Youtube and understanding what was going on a lot more, although with a bit of mental lag. I'm almost done with this book and just need another stretch.
metascribe commented on The Elements of Style by William Strunk
Finished the first chapter, covering "elementary rules of usage," which are a list of guiding tips that address common, more subtle mistakes in grammar, as well as uses of punctuation and syntactical sorting that promote clarity and precision. The next chapter seems to be on composition, which is larger-scale organization of writing.
metascribe started reading The Elements of Style by William Strunk
This is a book I remember being assigned in my high school AP English courses, an early introduction given its been traditionally used in university/college classrooms. Rereading to remind myself of some key ways to clean up my writing.
metascribe commented on Accounting and Finance for Managers (Fast Track MBA) by John Kind
So far I find this book to be much better coverage of music theory concepts than Michael Hewitt's Music Theory for Computer Musicians. So far, gets straight to the point, with much clearer and simpler though powerful definitions of musical theory concepts than the roundabout overviews of the aforementioned book.
metascribe started reading Accounting and Finance for Managers (Fast Track MBA) by John Kind
metascribe rated The Dissociative Mind: 4 stars
The Dissociative Mind by Elizabeth Howell
Drawing on the pioneering work of Janet, Freud, Sullivan, and Fairbairn and making extensive use of recent literature, Elizabeth Howell …
metascribe finished reading The Dissociative Mind by Elizabeth Howell
Finished reading this a few weeks ago. It was a good review of the different models of dissociation, although the book focused more on psychoanalysis / analytical psychology and did not incorporate any, or otherwise incorporated too few, neuroscientific studies of dissociation and dissociative symptoms. Its relationship to my own life could be felt in the context of my experience of incongruity in different areas in my life, that I've only become more aware of over time. My sense of self felt incoherent, vague, or fractured, and this was very much connected to my CPTSD triggers. It was insightful learning about the hypotheses of the genesis of structural dissociation at the level of personality, as it helped me trace my footsteps back to the kinds of strategies I used to handle trauma and how they relate to consequent structural dissociation or dissociative symptoms.
metascribe rated Podman in Action: 3 stars
Podman in Action by Daniel Walsh
The next generation of containers is here. Learn Podman directly from its creator, discover its exceptional security features, and start …
metascribe started reading Podman in Action by Daniel Walsh
metascribe commented on Understanding Symbolic Logic by Virginia Klenk
Have finally reached Unit 7 again, which covers the proof method for demonstrating argument validity. The proof method involves applying replacement rules and rules of inference on formulae to show that a conclusion does indeed follow from some set of premises with shared operands. Glad I finished taking notes on the previous Unit chapter so I can move on with reading.
metascribe started reading Hispaniola by Samuel M. Wilson
Taking a break from reading books on gender, I guess, so am now reading a bit more of mesearch. Having a Dominican background, I thought it would be interesting to learn about the Taíno of Quisqueya (so-called "Hispaniola"), and some of the Spanish colonial history on the island, as an introduction to Dominican history.