Short but clear.
User Profile
This link opens in a pop-up window
pwithnall's books
User Activity
RSS feed Back
pwithnall rated Glittering City: 4 stars
Glittering City by Cyprian Ekwensi (Penguin Modern: 32)
pwithnall reviewed Africa's Tarnished Name by Chinua Achebe (Penguin Modern: 28)
Review of 'Metalwork' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
A good introduction to all the basic processes of metalwork, but it hasn't aged too well. Particularly the final chapters about CNC are out of date. A lot of the practical guidance on how to use universal machines is repeated (they all use the same longitudinal beds). The illustrations and diagrams are helpful throughout, and each chapter is self-contained so you can dip in for reference as you need.
pwithnall reviewed Caves and karst of the Yorkshire Dales by Tony Waltham (BCRA cave studies series -- number 1)
pwithnall reviewed Northern England. by Robert William Rennison (Civil engineering heritage)
Review of 'Northern England.' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
A quick and somewhat interesting overview of various heritage bits of civil engineering the north of England. Many of the entries are simply a list of span dimensions and names of architects and engineers, which is not very interesting or useful. The more interesting entries are the longer ones which have some motivation for why a particular structure is important, and some information about its development and history.
pwithnall reviewed Helen Dillon's Garden Book by Helen Dillon
pwithnall reviewed Blue Mars by Kim Stanley Robinson (A Bantam spectra book)
Review of 'Blue Mars' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
I felt like I lived a lifetime while reading this book. Partially because it’s quite a long book, and partially because it seems to forego plot at some points, instead just following the (extended) lives of various characters as they while away their days enjoying flying, climbing, or cruising around their world.
Some interesting ideas, and some interesting politics, but at points felt like those things were only a loosely strung together collection of things the author wanted to include.
pwithnall reviewed Norwegian wood by Lars Mytting
pwithnall reviewed Wainwright in Scotland by A. Wainwright
pwithnall reviewed Rambling on by Mike Harding
pwithnall reviewed The Dales 30 by Jonathan Smith
Review of 'The Dales 30' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
Good route suggestions, clear and consider writing, and nice photographs. A nice way to guide people towards not just walking the Yorkshire Three Peaks.
pwithnall rated Wainwright's TV walks: 3 stars
pwithnall reviewed Canals by J. C. Gagg (The Observer's series)
Review of 'Canals' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Informative, but quite opinionated and a little condescending. It includes a lot of uncommon knowledge about canals (at least from my point of view), but occasionally dilutes it with irrelevant coverage of other things (like the wildlife you’ll find in a hedgerow). Overall, an interesting and quick read on canals, with the bonus that it’s also an interesting insight into people’s opinions on canals in the 80s.
pwithnall reviewed Composting with Worms by George Pilkington
Review of 'Composting with Worms' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
Informative, but slightly longer than it needed to be to convey the relevant information. It contained a lot of lists which would grow outdated over time (for example, comparisons and evaluations of worm composters which were available at the time of publishing). References were provided at the end, but not linked to from the text, which made some of the claimed benefits of vermiculture a little less credible. The book was slightly too evangelical at times to be credible either.