Jon PENNYCOOK reviewed Heretics of Dune by Frank Herbert
Review of 'Heretics of Dune' on 'Goodreads'
3 stars
It waa like something from the 50s or 60s with people with superpowers. In some ways, it reminded me of AE van Vogt.
It waa like something from the 50s or 60s with people with superpowers. In some ways, it reminded me of AE van Vogt.
This was hard-going from reading a lot of Dune in a few months. It took me a while to get into this one and get the hang of the plot. Generally I'd say every Dune since the first one, I struggle to work out the politics of it.
Then it got going and I quite enjoyed it, reasonably full of action. And then the Bene Gesserit ("good") and the Honored Matres ("bad") just get creepier and creepier with the sex-to-control-men thing. It's been building for a few books, but, to me, it feels like something someone writes to justify why they hate women. There are few named women in this that aren't a secret society using sex or breeding to control everyone else.
On a lighter note, towards the end, there is an impromptu sex fight between a man and a woman while others watch, where the person who orgasms …
This was hard-going from reading a lot of Dune in a few months. It took me a while to get into this one and get the hang of the plot. Generally I'd say every Dune since the first one, I struggle to work out the politics of it.
Then it got going and I quite enjoyed it, reasonably full of action. And then the Bene Gesserit ("good") and the Honored Matres ("bad") just get creepier and creepier with the sex-to-control-men thing. It's been building for a few books, but, to me, it feels like something someone writes to justify why they hate women. There are few named women in this that aren't a secret society using sex or breeding to control everyone else.
On a lighter note, towards the end, there is an impromptu sex fight between a man and a woman while others watch, where the person who orgasms is the loser of sex fight. I don't think it's supposed to be funny, but I laughed a lot.