Paul Oldham reviewed Early Riser by Jasper Fforde
An interesting idea but poorly executed
1 star
I'm a fan of Fforde's earlier works so I came to this with a great sense of anticipation but I was disappointed.
Let's start with the cover. What may not be obvious from the image on this page is that this hardback book was a big rectangular hole chopped into it through which you can see the first page (the beach scene). This makes the book awkward to hold and read as you can't put your fingers in that area.
Be that as it may I got as far as page 262 of 400 before I finally gave up on it. It's full of Fforde's usual gimmicks, like having a quote from another (fictional) work as the heading for each chapter and the whole plot revolves around another of his alternative worlds, and in particular in this one an alternative Wales, which is subject to what is not really an …
I'm a fan of Fforde's earlier works so I came to this with a great sense of anticipation but I was disappointed.
Let's start with the cover. What may not be obvious from the image on this page is that this hardback book was a big rectangular hole chopped into it through which you can see the first page (the beach scene). This makes the book awkward to hold and read as you can't put your fingers in that area.
Be that as it may I got as far as page 262 of 400 before I finally gave up on it. It's full of Fforde's usual gimmicks, like having a quote from another (fictional) work as the heading for each chapter and the whole plot revolves around another of his alternative worlds, and in particular in this one an alternative Wales, which is subject to what is not really an ice age but rather very extreme winters during which most humans hibernate (summers, although we never get to be in one of those other than in dreams, seem to be normal, so it's not an ice age in the normal sense).
With Ffordes other books the warped reality seems to work but with this one it really doesn't. For example I won't give away the plot twist but the business with Aurora and Toccata just isn't plausible, even in this alternative reality and I got bored with waiting for the plot to be revealed.
Thankfully my best beloved reminded me that I didn't need to finish a book if I wasn't enjoying it. So I didn't.