User Profile

Odin Halvorson

indubitablyodin@ramblingreaders.org

Joined 1 year, 11 months ago

I am a scholar, writer, pop-fiction fan, and tech enthusiast. My interests range from sci-fi and fantasy, to political and social theories, to philosophy, to tech, to history, to romance... the list basically goes on forever.

Learn more about me via my bio.link! bio.link/indubitablyodin

This link opens in a pop-up window

Odin Halvorson's books

To Read

Currently Reading

Naomi Novik: Crucible of gold (2012, Del Rey/Ballantine Books) 4 stars

"Naomi Novik's beloved series returns, with Capt. Will Laurence and his fighting dragon Temeraire once …

Not Quite as Bright as Gold

3 stars

There's a sense of the threadbare in this one, a plot pulled forward more for its own sake than from a feeling of inner motivation. Coming from the plod of the previous book, this mostly feels like an attempt to renew a status quo from earlier works: travel and action, but it continually feels contrived, with the writer's need to create tension and dissonance all-too plainly evident.

That said, there's still a lot to like about the book: the writing is crisp in many ways, and I find the general worldbuilding intreguing.

My largest qualms come mostly through a continuation of character growth degradation, especially on the part of the dragons. The intrinsic motivations for the dragons have been becoming steadily more and more frail, and Temeraire seems to be constantly mired in a sort of backward juvenile innocence that I find frustrating after his early potential for a rather …

avatar for indubitablyodin Odin Halvorson boosted

I've really come to appreciate the hard work of individuals that make the work by hosting and managing instances. As a big reader I really like so I can log all my books and reviews.

I've just financially contributed to the instance I use @ramblingreaders, run by @marcus, to show my support and to keep it going.

If you are a bookworm as well, do check them out, follow me at @robhardware@ramblingreaders.org, and consider supporting them too! https://opencollective.com/ramblingreaders

Naomi Novik: Tongues of Serpents (Temeraire, #6) 4 stars

Tongues of Serpents is the sixth novel in the Temeraire alternate history/fantasy series by American …

While one of the weaker books, it has some shining moments.

3 stars

Content warning Minor general plot spoilers

Naomi Novik: Victory of Eagles (Temeraire, #5) 5 stars

Victory of Eagles is the fifth novel in the Temeraire alternate history/fantasy series by American …

The strongest addition to the series yet!

5 stars

This book finally gives us more of Temeraire's own perspectives on life and the world, and showcases a strong bout of character development that had been previously somewhat slower to evolve. Likewise with Laurence, who must finally confront the inherent conflict between his inner morality and the damning ethics of his country. At the same time, there are deeper moral and ethical questions at work alongside a rather thrilling series of battles. All backed by the repugnance of the British Lords and commanders. Even in those moments where I became a little annoyed with the story, I found myself quickly turned around by strong plot choices and a balance of action and consequence.

Naomi Novik: Empire of Ivory 4 stars

Empire of Ivory is the fourth novel in the Temeraire alternate history/fantasy series by American …

Variously sharp and muddled, but still excellent

4 stars

The first portion of this book is a bit muddled, but the story flows well from hooks planted two books earlier. Again, we get another major culture and their treatment of dragons, and we finally address one of the most glaring problems of the story's timeline: the slave trade out of Africa. There's a lot to like here, even if some of the story goes a bit slow, and other moments feel a little too contrived.

Naomi Novik: Black Powder War (EBook, 2009, HarperCollins) 5 stars

Naomi Novik's stunning series of novels follow the global adventures of Captain William Laurence and …

Another improvement to a strong series

5 stars

The sense of movement in the plot is greatly aided by the vast range of landscapes through which the characters pass in the third Temeraire novel. We finally get some major land combat, and the story further highlights the differences between how the various cultures treat their dragon populations (it's no surprise that China continues to come out ahead). We also get our first true taste of the French, which is nice as they've been a relatively distant foe thus far. While this story is heavily action-focused, it maintains a powerful consideration of social norms, power dynamics, and the inhernet stupidity of human beings.

Naomi Novik: Throne of Jade (2006, Ballantine Books) 4 stars

Captain Will Laurence and his noble dragon Temeraire battle against Bonaparte's invading forces. When China …

An improvement on an already strong introduction.

5 stars

The second book in the Temeraire series brings us to China, with an excellent juxtaposition of Chinese culture and custom to the unhappy state of affairs in England. Lawrence is able to develop more as a character, and we finally start to see Temeraire himself have a stronger personality. Excellent subtle philosophy and political analysis at work behind the scenes, and far better action-sequences overall than what were presented in the first book. If the central battle is somewhat over-the-top, it is to be at least forgiven for its sense of unending ruthlessness.

Naomi Novik: His Majesty's Dragon (EBook, 2006, Random House Publishing Group) 3 stars

Aerial combat brings a thrilling new dimension to the Napoleonic Wars as valiant warriors rise …

A Book That Has It All

4 stars

Content warning Very minor spoilers for one plot point (the same as you'd get from reading the back cover).

Philip Reeve: A web of air (2011, Scholastic) 4 stars

In Mayda, a post-apocalyptic city off the coast of Portugal, a brilliant young engineer and …

Something worthwhile, with a taste of heartsickness that one identifies with the series.

4 stars

The second entry in the Fever Crumb Trilogy is a reasonable offering, though it tries to do too much with too little. There's a steady flow of adventure, and while Fever remains a relatively uninteresting character, she gets herself into enough interesting situations that it's all okay. A bit of a mixed plate with her relationship arc, which didn't commit strongly enough to any of the options the writer had available (and which the relationship of book three doesn't nearly come close to sorting out).

Overall, a fair read if you're a fan of the original series.

Philip Reeve: Fever Crumb (2011, Scholastic) 4 stars

A lone girl sets out on a mission to retrieve lost technology in a bleak …

A reasonable addition to the Mortal Engines world

4 stars

While nowhere near as strong as the original series, the brevity of the book works in its favor, offering a shorter form tale for what is a much thinner plot. It's worth a read for fans of the main series.